Silicon Valley Byte Size - The Allianz Technology Trust Podcast
The cost of competitive advantage: What AI gives us and what it takes away
AI promises businesses greater efficiency, lower costs and better decision-making, but what happens when it begins to replace the entry-level work through which employees learn their profession? In this episode of Silicon Valley Bite Size, Cherry Reynard is joined by Mike Seidenberg, Lead Manager of Allianz Technology Trust, to explore how companies can embrace AI while continuing to develop talent, maintain strong corporate cultures and build the skills they will need for the future.
Mike Seidenberg (MS): : It is the board asking CEOs, what are we doing about AI? How do we make our customers happier? How do we take costs out and make our products better? How do we grow revenues, which in turn grow profits? That’s the competitive advantage. Once companies smell it, they execute on it because most companies want to win.
Cherry Reynard (CR) : Hello and welcome to Silicon Valley Byte Size, where we explore some of the biggest ideas shaping technology and investing. AI promises businesses greater efficiency, lower costs and better decision-making, but every competitive advantage comes with trade-offs. So, what happens when AI begins to replace the entry-level work through which generations of employees learn their profession? To discuss this, I'm joined by Mike Seidenberg, lead manager of the Allianz Technology Trust. Mike, great to see you.
MS: Nice to see you.
CR: Now, Mike, you've often said that technology can create a powerful competitive advantage. So, let's talk initially about how it does that.
MS: If you go back and look cycle after cycle at these big secular themes, you've seen that companies that embrace and adopt the various technologies tend to create a competitive advantage. They do that not for the sake of the technology, because nobody really invests in technology for the sake of technology. People invest in technology for basically three things, in my opinion. One is to help grow revenues. Two is to help reduce costs. Three is to have better customer service. We've seen these three pillars of technology use cases for the last, call it, 30-plus years in Silicon Valley and globally. It's not just Silicon Valley. Those are the drivers of technology adoption. We are in the midst of one of those secular themes right now, which is the implementation and use of artificial intelligence. We're seeing varying degrees of uptake by businesses. Here again, they're using it to make their business better. They're not using it just for the sake of technology.
CR: So, AI adoption really has to accelerate all three areas.
MS: Well, not necessarily all three areas. It has to impact one of the three, and if you think about how technology products are sold, they're typically sold on a business use case. As somebody who used to sell tech software many decades ago, you basically are building a use case internally for a company to make that leap of faith and buy the technology, and AI is no different. I think the difference in AI is there are more implications of replacing rudimentary tasks that traditionally haven't been automated. That brings up a variety of potential questions for businesses.
CR: Is there anything that particularly concerns you about the way AI might reshape the workplace?
MS: I'm somebody that has college-aged kids. I do think about entry-level jobs, where a lot of those jobs are equally as important in teaching you how to be a quote-unquote corporate citizen. AI has the possibility of automating those tasks, which, if you extrapolate, means there may be fewer entry-level jobs. Then if you go down that thread, if there are fewer entry-level jobs, how do people understand how businesses work? Here again, I'm looking forward a little bit. I don't think that's the reality today, but I do think about newly minted people entering the workforce and how their experience is probably going to be very different from my experience.
CR: I like that idea of the corporate citizen and training them to be corporate citizens.
MS: It's really important.
CR: What could businesses lose if they don't have these junior people coming through the system?
MS: What they could lose is a whole group of people that start at a certain time and work their way up through a business. That may be more challenging, and it may be more challenging for people to understand what the corporate culture is, what the work ethic is and how to behave. I mean, there are just a lot of intangibles that you learn from your entry-level jobs, depending on where you start. I'm thinking mainly around the Fortune 2000 type of businesses. I think it'll be more challenging for businesses to impart their framework on people. It's going to take more effort. If there are fewer entry-level jobs being created, that's going to take some effort by businesses.
CR: And I'm assuming that possibly remote and hybrid working further complicates that situation.
MS: Just adding layers of complexity, I think that's already the reality today. Most businesses have adopted potentially four days in the office, one day remote, depending on what the balance is. I've worked in businesses for a long time, so it doesn't really impact me because I basically understand what the roles and responsibilities are. I think if you're somebody that graduated from college and this is your first experience; remote working adds a layer of complexity to the situation. You further add that layer of complexity with AI being part of your job, part of your daily experience. A lot of the tasks that are being replaced aren't particularly ones that use a high level of your, quote unquote, education. There could be an opportunity to be more creative, more effective, sell more things, whatever the ‘more’ is. But I do think that there's a challenge there for corporations and for employees.
CR: Presumably you're not saying that businesses should slow down their adoption of AI in response, but it's more of a problem that they've got to manage.
MS: I don't think they will slow down their adoption of AI, right? Because what we've seen is the competitive advantage it creates. Whether it was the movement to the cloud or the movement from mainframes to client-server computing, that competitive advantage is clear. Once companies smell it, they execute on it because most companies want to win and want to grow revenues and profits. I don't think that you'll have any gating factor on this. We've seen this just by the demand that we're seeing right now for AI-related capacity. I think what you will see is how you implement that as a tool to make your employees more productive, more effective. If you extrapolate that back as an employee, this notion of embracing new technologies and embracing new things becomes important, right? Because you really want to be able to add that to your toolkit. It's a foreign concept for a lot of people. Probably less so for younger people and more so for people like myself.
CR: Are there any companies that are doing that particularly well? using technology and not simply replacing the entry-level human experience?
MS: You point to the companies that are not only developing it but also using it, in no order. If you think about companies like Alphabet, Microsoft and Amazon, as well as probably leading industrial companies, whether it's Caterpillar or other manufacturers, these are businesses that really view technology as an opportunity, not as a threat. It's the usual suspects and probably a thousand other companies that I didn't name.
But I think the important thing here is that if you don't focus upper management on understanding what it means to your business, there is a real risk. That's why, if you go and talk to companies, it's not just upper management talking about it.
It is the board asking CEOs, what are we doing about AI? What are we doing about our employees embracing it and learning to use it? It's really this top-down, overarching area of focus.
Here again, we've seen that before with other things. If you think about cybersecurity and roll the clock back, so much of the spend on cybersecurity was not just driven by the CEO being concerned. It was at board level. It was the board saying to that CEO, I don't want to be on the front page of the FT. I don't want to be on the front page of The Wall Street Journal. These are powerful themes that tend to have lots of constituents basically asking the question, what are we doing about this?
CR: So, with that top-down focus, the strongest businesses are presumably not just saying we can automate this part of the business, but they're saying this is how we can re-engineer our process to make more efficient using AI.
MS: It's really this notion of embracing and finding use cases that go back to those three things I talked about earlier. How do we make our customers happier? How do we take costs out and make our products better? It's not just taking costs out. It's making products better. How do we have a better relationship with our customer? How do we grow revenues, which in turn grow profits? But it requires investment, not only in time but also in money.
CR: How are you looking at companies? How are you assessing whether a company is using AI intelligently and effectively?
MS: We spend a lot of time thinking about that and talking to the companies, really understanding: are they a beneficiary or are they a victim? I would tell you that not all segments in technology are created equal in this aspect. We have seen some disruption from subsectors in technology that I think will find it challenging to come back into relevancy. But I think probing is the right approach. We're asking lots of questions to understand what companies can do to make their products better using AI or, in some cases, are they an arms dealer? I shouldn't use that analogy these days, but are they a supplier to the artificial intelligence industry? Start thinking about semiconductor companies and power management companies and the like. It's something that is top of mind for us and something that we are very aware of and really want to understand, so we don't end up with investments that could potentially be victims of AI leapfrogging them.
CR: Okay. And so just to sum up, the answer is not to resist the technology. It's to manage the consequences of that technology.
MS: I always use the example of those old photos of people doing accounting, wearing those green visors and putting things in ledgers. In fact, if you go around London, sometimes you see offices with these old ledgers, which are great looking, but it's the same notion. You could still use people to do that, or you could embrace computing and software to do the same thing and probably get much better results with far fewer errors. Not surprisingly, I'm a really big believer in the use of technology, given my career. But I think you really run the risk of potentially becoming obsolete if you don't at least figure out how it can make your business better.
CR: We'll wrap up there. Thanks, that was an interesting perspective on this powerful new trend. Thanks again for joining us today, Mike.
MS: It's really good to be here.
CR: If you'd like to learn more about Allianz Technology Trust and the team's approach to the long-term opportunities and challenges created by artificial intelligence, you'll find portfolio insights, performance information, and the latest commentary on the Allianz Technology Trust website. If you're enjoying Silicon Valley Byte Size, please like, subscribe and follow the series. Thanks for joining us.